The Circle – Metamorphosis – EP Review

Artist: The Circle 

Album Title: Metamorphosis 

Label: Independent Release 

Date of Release: 23 April 2021 

Another of my magical evenings spent searching for new music has come up trumps yet again. Without trawling my inbox, Bandcamp, YouTube, my Haulix account and other corners of the Internet, I would never have come across The Circle. And had I not, my life would be much the poorer for it. After reading this review and checking out the music for yourself, I hope you feel the same way.  

The Circle is the chosen moniker for a trio of musicians ‘from the depths of Germany’, as their social media pages declare. Whilst I cannot accurately or confidently name any of the musicians, I can tell you that they display the confidence to refer to their musical output as ‘art metal’. I’m never really sure what art metal really means if I’m being completely honest, so I’m going to take the executive decision to ditch that term and use my own descriptors.  

That idea seemed a good one initially, but now that I’m forced to commit something to paper, I realise just how difficult it is to describe this music. There are elements of technical death metal, symphonic metal, prog, doom/death, and black metal, with lots more besides just lurking in the shadows. Hints of Fleshgod Apocalypse, Dimmu Borgir, and Ghosts Of Atlantis all rear their heads to a greater or lesser extent at points on ‘Metamorphosis’. This is theatrical, melancholy, grandiose, and heavy music but with a wonderfully melodic vein that runs right through the music, meaning that I cannot tear myself away from it. You all know by now what a sucker I am for beautiful melodies, and for my money, that’s what turns this record into a home run for me.  

It is astonishing to think that this release is the debut for The Circle, because it sounds so assured, so well-crafted, and it has a fittingly strong production that does the music justice. The guitars have a gratifying muscularity, the rhythm section is not lost in the mix, and the orchestration, of which there’s plenty, doesn’t overawe the more metallic elements of the music. What I’m still unsure of though, is whether to refer to ‘Metamorphosis’ as an EP or an album. It contains just four songs, but lasts for around 27 minutes, plenty long enough it seems for some death metal or grindcore acts to declare it an album. But do you know what? Who cares? It’s the music that matters most and on that, I’m happy to declare ‘Metamorphosis’ an unmitigated success.  

First up is ‘Chapter I: Angst’ that rises up out of the silence in a genuinely sinister manner, as if emerging from hell itself. The drums are arresting, belting out a punishing, slow beat, alongside which heavy riffs churn, fast-picked lead notes add an uncomfortable dissonance, and depraved, deep and guttural growls add malevolence. Then a lone violin emerges to duet with some brutal doom-laden riffs to create a rich melancholy. When the heaviness drops away, the bass can be heard pulsating like the black heart of the music, and the song suddenly reminds me of My Dying Bride. Then, out of nowhere, the darkness parts and in comes a delicate, beautiful melody accented by clean spoken-word vocals. The juxtaposition is quite stark, but incredibly smoothly done, especially when clean vocals replace the growls, and the guitars offer something more subtle, but no less captivating. There’s time for a really cool lead guitar break and an increase in atmospheric synths to bathe the more melodic soundscape, adding further texture in the process, as the song draws to a majestic close.  

Already smitten, I pray that the remaining three songs are as strong as the opener. I am rewarded handsomely too, as there’s absollutely no let-up in quality throughout.  

‘Chapter II: Verzweiflung’ is quite possibly the most overtly theatrical of the compositions on ‘Metamorphosis’. That said, it opens with more of a standard symphonic black metal approach, where the keys bathe relentless blastbeats, staccato riffs, and more venomous growls. But then, we’re treated to another beautiful melody, complete with passionate clean vocals, and from there, the track meanders from idea to idea with surprising aplomb. A minimalist section comprised of spoken-word lyrics atop sparse guitars and the whispers of tortured souls is intriguing, giving way to one of my favourite, catchiest riffs on the EP. Cleverly maintaining the atmosphere, the track ebbs and flows from theatrical Gothic trappings to technical death metal, to rousing bombast with ease and clarity of purpose.  

The intro to ‘Chapter III: Zorn’ is a frenetic whirlwind of black metal intensity but, whilst the drums are loathe to cease their relentless double-pedal battery, the remainder of the instruments settle to create something a little more melodic and majestic as the song progresses, the crowning moment of which is a chorus-like section where clean vocals compliment a strong melody before the musicians veer off in other directions once more.  

The final song, ‘Chapter IV: Erlösung’ is a meaty eight minutes, but it uses the time wisely to create a powerful ending to this debut outing for The Circle. The slower, more melodic introduction, complete with choir-like keys, and layers of synths is incredibly elegant but, as with the preceding three songs, the mysterious band don’t remain static for too long. It’s fair to say that this might be the most consistently melodic of the four songs, with fewer forays into the greater extremities. However, it doesn’t suffer as a result, or lose any of its impact. In fact, those moments when the crushing guitar riffs break through are all the more potent as a result. But I have to be honest and say that some of the melodic sensibilities within this final piece are simply stunning; acoustic guitars, violin, and delicate clean vocals come together to raise the hairs on my neck, especially in the closing stages. There’s an echo of Witherfall to be heard, as the band carry us to the end in powerful yet emotional fashion, the track cleverly deconstructing until it stops dead, the sudden silence almost deafening.  

In conclusion, I can only say that The Circle have rather deftly blown me away. It may only be four songs, but the quality displayed within and throughout ‘Metamorphosis’ is astounding. Whether you’re a fan of bludgeoning extreme metal, or heavy music with a softer, more melodic side, I guarantee you’ll take to this band as strongly as I have. Call it ‘art metal’ if you like, but I prefer to simply call it magnificent.  

The Score Of Much Metal: 92% 

Further reviews from 2021:

Wooden Veins – In Finitude

Plaguestorm – Purifying Fire

Drift Into Black – Patterns Of Light

Alluvial – Sarcoma

White Moth Black Butterfly – The Cost Of Dreaming – Album Review

Silver Lake by Esa Holopainen

Bloodbound – Creatures From The Dark Realm

Nahaya – Vital Alchemy

Frost* – Day And Age

Obsolete Theory – Downfall

Vola – Witness

Acolyte – Entropy

Dordeduh – Har

Subterranean Masquerade – Mountain Fever

Seth – La Morsure Du Christ

The Circle – Metamorphosis

Nordjevel – Fenriir

Vreid – Wild North West

Temtris – Ritual Warfare

Astrakhan – A Slow Ride Towards Death

Akiavel – Vae Victis

Gojira – Fortitude

Hideous Divinity – LV-426

Benthos – II

Evile – Hell Unleashed

Ninkharsag – The Dread March Of Solemn Gods

Bodom After Midnight – Paint The Sky With Blood

Morrigu – In Turbulence

Mother Of All – Age Of The Solipsist

Throne – Pestilent Dawn

Sweet Oblivion (Geoff Tate) – Relentless

Exanimis – Marionnettiste

Dvne – Etemen Ænka

Cannibal Corpse – Violence Unimagined

Arion – Vultures Die Alone

Maestitium – Tale Of The Endless

Wode – Burn In Many Mirrors

Everdawn – Cleopatra

Unflesh – Inhumation

Mourning Dawn – Dead End Euphoria

Wheel – Resident Human

Wythersake – Antiquity

Odd Dimension – The Blue Dawn

Metalite – A Virtual World

Cryptosis – Bionic Swarm

Ghosts Of Atlantis – 3.6.2.4

Memoriam – To The End

Aversed – Impermanent

Secret Sphere – Lifeblood

Enforced – Kill Grid

Liquid Tension Experiment – LTE3

Turbulence – Frontal

Iotunn – Access All Worlds

Warrior Path – The Mad King

Stortregn – Impermanence

Mariana’s Rest – Fata Morgana

Orden Ogan – Final Days

Witherfall – Curse Of Autumn

Plague Weaver – Ascendant Blasphemy

Ephemerald – Between The Glimpses Of Hope

Paranorm – Empyrean

Einherjer – North Star

Epica – Omega

Humanity’s Last Breath – Välde

Simulacrum – Genesis

Forhist – Forhist

Evergrey – Escape Of The Phoenix

Empyrium – Über den Sternen

Moonspell – Hermitage

Infernalizer – The Ugly Truth

Temperance – Melodies Of Green And Blue EP

Malice Divine – Malice Divine

Revulsion – Revulsion

Demon King – The Final Tyranny EP

Dragony – Viribus Unitis

Soen – Imperial

Angelus Apatrida – Angelus Apatrida

Oceana – The Pattern

Therion – Leviathan

Tribulation – Where The Gloom Becomes Sound

Asphyx – Necroceros

W.E.T. – Retransmission

Labyrinth – Welcome To The Absurd Circus

TDW – The Days The Clock Stopped

Need – Norchestrion: A Song For The End

You can also check out my other reviews from previous years right here:

2020 reviews

2019 reviews
2018 reviews
2017 reviews
2016 reviews
2015 reviews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s